{"_canonicalization":{"envelope_id":"axm_ + sha256(envelope minus {signature, axiom_id, anchors})","envelope_signature":"ed25519(envelope minus {signature, axiom_id})","json":"sort_keys=True, separators=(',',':'), ensure_ascii=False, allow_nan=False, utf-8","leaf_hash":"sha256(0x00 || canonical_json(envelope_full))","seal_signature":"ed25519(seal minus {signature, sig_algorithm})"},"axiom_id":"axm_3c5299ae54b34f5b936276c395fdfbf7f89bdb22c019db5a180b0177c2dcdb58","bitcoin_anchor":{"bitcoin_attestations":[],"calendar_attestations":[],"ots_url":"","stamped_at":"","status":"pending_next_stamp"},"envelope":{"anchors":[{"chain":"crovia.axiom_graph","height":1783447213,"merkle_proof":"tpa_chain_h260758","root_at_anchor":"tpa_chain_h260758"}],"axiom_id":"axm_3c5299ae54b34f5b936276c395fdfbf7f89bdb22c019db5a180b0177c2dcdb58","axiom_type":"AX.NEC","body":{"canon_version":"NEC-v1.0","observation_epoch":1783447213,"observations":[{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xce69e75956b74d5ecdcb06b3e981ebcfeb958ebeacb3fd2d45f946b48ed5833a","commitment_y":"0xdfdb479ddb75e14fba7c8d747dcd6fc4ce565a3854c88e483f85a1326eb44d2b","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":true,"necessity_id":"NEC#1","necessity_name":"Missing explicit data provenance","severity_label":"CRITICAL"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x4e6f42a28c161f7faa68a7490de3c0262255248480cf83bcfdca1b67e5be48ac","commitment_y":"0x41f10e4a947fa35bd4140cae8d219458cf8a690aaf0a6b21a7bc23daf2eb7e70","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":4,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","EU General Data Protection Regulation","California Consumer Privacy Act"],"necessity_id":"NEC#10","necessity_name":"Missing temporal validity and revocation metadata","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xd5fa9a12a510bf54098e11b769a50aa76ef506cf135698fee473be5d40383822","commitment_y":"0xc3a2932e4c6a295552e6d2a6d7ac87f1b02a30338227d753b3104207125aa01d","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","United States FTC Act","OECD AI Principles"],"necessity_id":"NEC#11","necessity_name":"Missing known limitations documentation","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xc22f150849fc9d55ca347ba80f51f210d0efd00a237f7fe9a0fe9fcc4b138e21","commitment_y":"0x33ac96929194f0cc37fd2f125414314aa7ef7e4dd36d3778100befb37514c2fa","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":4,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","EU General Data Protection Regulation","United States FTC Act"],"necessity_id":"NEC#12","necessity_name":"Missing bias and fairness assessment","severity_label":"CRITICAL"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x6fac5624a54fda42c35ee8519087cebc276ca627f8da75b24c926b7a37f134cf","commitment_y":"0xc0c8032b6dae0ed78406596e7d6ac32000c3b893c5790745640c8376101182b5","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":true,"necessity_id":"NEC#13","necessity_name":"Missing accountable entity","severity_label":"CRITICAL"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x69f30e1889b8eeecd8e18a6fddd6886adad95dfadc6461b8e6ce39c12c24cad9","commitment_y":"0xf2d2052e90f8287c026bca075aa30690ba4b0f69401e41b326ab56e8f1da8d33","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":2,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System"],"necessity_id":"NEC#14","necessity_name":"Missing data preprocessing documentation","severity_label":"MODERATE"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xd3c40b163acf0bad3b51f161e63b55ac6337a0b374902a720f1ef3e1cf0614ac","commitment_y":"0xfc367270b47a8104562267278438ab2868a5d9ba463ea5525fd778b455c28a55","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":2,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","China Provisions on Generative AI"],"necessity_id":"NEC#15","necessity_name":"Missing multilingual capability scope","severity_label":"LOW"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xd4a151140dcdaf21df3cab7e15cb66a69d398c1a91c0d2992ed6f44d73d35e6c","commitment_y":"0x4e520cd5c4ec945ca352967b22d039842913028aa94060d195d1b412390e7502","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System","United Kingdom AI Regulation"],"necessity_id":"NEC#16","necessity_name":"Missing security vulnerability assessment","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xfb94acd3039762e9b123543ab95a746ea644be6cc7ebb5345c8dcdb41bb75e46","commitment_y":"0x2d027402a2722b72850196617c8e0e3042ff0f9278703d76d843fd6ba8b27544","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":2,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System"],"necessity_id":"NEC#17","necessity_name":"Missing deployment and integration guidelines","severity_label":"MODERATE"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x9450de0728aa416ad6c34a33c4775db0fa7ed7ed9248de1f5988d00f24b8a0bf","commitment_y":"0x946f4e07f151537d05019e9df9c6cadc7364b67877959c3bf297a2fc042093cc","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","China Provisions on Generative AI","United Kingdom AI Regulation"],"necessity_id":"NEC#18","necessity_name":"Missing incident reporting mechanism","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x81400217a666282d7e8d428ece8210dc9d620c49bfa6f90acf136a495c4876f3","commitment_y":"0x7bc4bf1e27ba9c500fd7acf5377bab6f4bb3d904cb1181649b243632c5d282d8","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":2,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System"],"necessity_id":"NEC#19","necessity_name":"Missing version history and changelog","severity_label":"LOW"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xb01f577362654bc61795d0c5e591cd7bf3a6a0dd2d326634b631f75d7e02e8f9","commitment_y":"0x85932f7f456f9fa00f8e8db2ed2d18519fcc4a766118174d5b3cc931d80c9388","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":true,"necessity_id":"NEC#2","necessity_name":"Missing explicit license attribution","severity_label":"CRITICAL"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xc42aa25adf56abbc9c71900d30073da3155d95a4b442b55955db463c18d46816","commitment_y":"0x72f03b9c193dab5f7ef5f4e4064ba4e99326d0b2b53dbfe8c129ad86608b2f62","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","EU General Data Protection Regulation","OECD AI Principles"],"necessity_id":"NEC#20","necessity_name":"Missing downstream impact assessment","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x218a6b17fd405dc217f2f5b2ee45709b7883d7dccc74f889f68ef48f9f2fd868","commitment_y":"0x49dd8a46442ebc9a31a5590c15d9676e7dc5b54adf6842a5d3b46ef4fc0155fa","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","China Provisions on Generative AI","OECD AI Principles"],"necessity_id":"NEC#3","necessity_name":"Missing model architecture disclosure","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x7b9302c97dfc5a5d5a5d07de34dcbce3c6b4ed5757064fce038ed549e06dc918","commitment_y":"0xd1a9e2d09004cdf080b1dd1c64a024746555d742871deed625f60f287a923d8d","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System","OECD AI Principles"],"necessity_id":"NEC#4","necessity_name":"Missing training methodology documentation","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x5ab67de22101da4ba5bfa280414de75ddd2a3a81b4fc9008eb6334eed042945c","commitment_y":"0xae890e40faf5d08d8d4658608a769f9420294416948df5ae4a611d3bfcb81db5","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":true,"necessity_id":"NEC#5","necessity_name":"Missing evaluation and benchmark results","severity_label":"MODERATE"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x9d77065a9eed6c9c5959c14005e04e76ab78fa0395454a478c77d399114a2570","commitment_y":"0x79bb4959caa6d8fb1358379fb7793b37b806d5a33aac9dce2d1bf4dc0fa2fc8e","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":4,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","China Provisions on Generative AI","United Kingdom AI Regulation"],"necessity_id":"NEC#6","necessity_name":"Missing safety and risk evaluation","severity_label":"CRITICAL"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x3fa009cfe8397952af0f4cc19b83eb111bc6c6ae54d8d70c0025d0f30331751a","commitment_y":"0x163d4734b32d2d3edc67a0d2abd7aa3bbaa335bd23201b0bce019dc706ec67c","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","United States FTC Act","OECD AI Principles"],"necessity_id":"NEC#7","necessity_name":"Missing usage scope declaration","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xe3e37561ec8217e1e660c90295e90850cf9c52b3a884bdaa776f7e6ce2001e6d","commitment_y":"0xdde288f719bb5b64e788de964ef4d597ac76a858718c6371462a332df39620a3","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":2,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System"],"necessity_id":"NEC#8","necessity_name":"Missing environmental impact disclosure","severity_label":"MODERATE"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x63aad26af6a37703ea36d17b09251d820781b00d49c715cc9d812d5b14e5158f","commitment_y":"0x23c0ee6324c51ee74e2bd734a0fc4ca60bc1ce8ca30cb9b8d16497ac1c69caae","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":true,"necessity_id":"NEC#9","necessity_name":"Missing human oversight mechanism","severity_label":"CRITICAL"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-07T18:00:13Z","receipt_hash":"fa2d82fe043a40ebb30bebec8b6bd29ae760267fd336c44c6eca91d1c0ab4396","tier":"OPEN","tpa_id":"TPA-6066d423389c5e17ac603690","version":"1.0.0"},"confidence":{"method":"deterministic"},"decision":"POSITIVE","issued_at":"2026-07-07T18:00:13Z","notes":"TPA TPA-6066d423389c5e17ac603690 retrofitted from Crovia TPA chain","object":{"captured_by":"crovia.tpa.canon_nec","primary_source_url":"https://registry.croviatrust.com/api/tpa/TPA-6066d423389c5e17ac603690"},"predecessors":[],"schema":"crovia.axiom.v1","signature":"ed25519:f41b21a45b218442fdc21726a9d10c416c0075a3415d9562014e667bb8c1d4e697ae41361e8064774c902b6dd7de42440ffb0e56bffcb2db90c47f88b5db7a04","signer":"crovia.substrate","subject":{"source_collector":"tpa_v1","target_id":"openbmb/RLHF-V"},"tsa":{"authority":"crovia.substrate.bootstrap","rfc3161_token":"{\"kind\":\"crovia.bootstrap.tsa\",\"source_jsonl\":\"/var/www/registry/data/tpa_latest.json\",\"source_seal_merkle_root\":\"tpa_chain_h260758\",\"upgrade_path\":\"Sessione H \\u2014 OpenTimestamps weekly anchor\"}"},"zk_mode":"clear","zk_proof":null},"ledger":{"leaf_hash":"c5b72762b485423075cbb210666084b567607f9330c3f1b1455e3c39f492c305","leaf_index":291385,"ledger_path":"/opt/crovia/substrate/axiom_ledger.jsonl"},"merkle_proof":{"hash_alg":"sha256","leaf_prefix":"0x00","node_prefix":"0x01","odd_leaf_rule":"duplicate_last","path":[{"sibling":"5ec63b2771e5d79777f151c5fa5b2f2c3f55e017a3613fb4ba908d174cc24b63","side":"left"},{"sibling":"641d1d5d600acbbb98f0beac493b54104610ca96103e06b0fe4eb161ecb51064","side":"right"},{"sibling":"8b9515d53a9f8e1db79fd543eb6f42732607bd87a16713b2fda8d3825ca0f116","side":"right"},{"sibling":"bd125e7868c354d81dd4850616259eda8f0324b8730325715865f76afac0f307","side":"left"},{"sibling":"942b902405ea2f0e2602665cafcb447189a9af2a992ffd59398c0b8765a18244","side":"left"},{"sibling":"088ed05602fdbde17171702af374b34c6e5bcc32ba97ff37a03bd2be3a39af9a","side":"left"},{"sibling":"501ef936c297eeed7f3c57aa5fe651b7eadbc1914cc7fbd4872d1cc667889811","side":"right"},{"sibling":"f3829d7ffaae5b135dd6097e3f1796270f1611d63fdb1b376fbe19b94ef3b97c","side":"right"},{"sibling":"9f401010fe7709ad91602d3cf497fab32063d38b5c17be6c22b5933e4b2f7b44","side":"right"},{"sibling":"d017b0814688bf3a842df5280d710bc470e7944c63e1799b67b2ebe00b13e28e","side":"left"},{"sibling":"1fc9f360c785b5d3d6ed1d6775f5252874a420e6242a0400b5b9890a6a7f2d27","side":"right"},{"sibling":"9e404eeec251e7ac2a22568a5c57a28f17457ef4a19abf107ac25a8830498ee2","side":"right"},{"sibling":"76855b4804c75c52bf97aa34358950d42d6103cdc1a86be5f0a2c8de4d65c106","side":"left"},{"sibling":"a75ab4319e241beeddb1b3f5705febe0422937926c3479923ccfb0b0082fa4e3","side":"left"},{"sibling":"bd04fa605f883bfb2b81510d045b1e85e555a03da3be083619f61384dfe40ff8","side":"left"},{"sibling":"8e270b364e2ca42cef3481f679997357bdb489607debdf193c4c230a75155527","side":"right"},{"sibling":"37581540800d4a46136e226d28c3fc0cd8933e506837f7bbb58116b2e5eef68b","side":"right"},{"sibling":"9b2f61fced88582c66ebcddb34724f570d79cae1c7dbc1d36835750f64eccaea","side":"right"},{"sibling":"1cecb7f447febd025aac272837c80de218aecc6485d2395a509b2a1f1b9c746e","side":"left"}]},"schema":"crovia.axiom_proof.v1","seal":{"first_collector_run_id":"","first_receipt_hash":"","jsonl_path":"/opt/crovia/substrate/axiom_ledger.jsonl","key_id":"430895f101d38164","last_collector_run_id":"","last_receipt_hash":"","leaf_count":291393,"merkle_root":"caaf41498dc763dde8a3e61a202ed8e4b8e8c8d20345fa527164ddea2cdfa126","public_key_hex":"cf742e26f75669dc673cb5c0786a1ae23ae8ca19c347317192ce40c28a7ff25c","run_id":"hourly_json_retrofit_20260707T183701Z","schema":"crovia.seal.v1","seal_family_version":"crovia-seal-family/1","seal_kind":"substrate_batch","sealed_at":"2026-07-07T18:38:16Z","sig_algorithm":"ed25519","signature":"775c850e23b1883329bf3749ab89dc530df658b45bed04077e590b8fd85daac3319b35d8058e6730560e51037031d111762691f255a25d47ad0cdd5940a2ad04","signer_version":"1.1.0"},"trust_root":{"key_id":"430895f101d38164","public_key_hex":"cf742e26f75669dc673cb5c0786a1ae23ae8ca19c347317192ce40c28a7ff25c","signature_algorithm":"ed25519","url":"/registry/canon/TRUST_ROOT.md"},"verifier":{"spec":"/registry/canon/AXIOM_RECEIPT_v1.md","url":"/v/axm_3c5299ae54b34f5b936276c395fdfbf7f89bdb22c019db5a180b0177c2dcdb58"}}