{"_canonicalization":{"envelope_id":"axm_ + sha256(envelope minus {signature, axiom_id, anchors})","envelope_signature":"ed25519(envelope minus {signature, axiom_id})","json":"sort_keys=True, separators=(',',':'), ensure_ascii=False, allow_nan=False, utf-8","leaf_hash":"sha256(0x00 || canonical_json(envelope_full))","seal_signature":"ed25519(seal minus {signature, sig_algorithm})"},"axiom_id":"axm_716fd6628b213940090641cf8bf9b0f4e8e44ffe819e984cdeac58f943f82c5f","bitcoin_anchor":{"bitcoin_attestations":["bitcoin_block_949451"],"calendar_attestations":["https://finney.calendar.eternitywall.com","https://btc.calendar.catallaxy.com","https://alice.btc.calendar.opentimestamps.org","https://bob.btc.calendar.opentimestamps.org"],"ots_url":"/registry/data/substrate/anchors/77fc9c28fae777b81da5b495b3115474df6592dfac590333213d3bdf8b94a9b3.ots","stamped_at":"2026-05-15T03:00:03Z","status":"bitcoin"},"envelope":{"anchors":[{"chain":"crovia.axiom_graph","height":0,"merkle_proof":"spider_vendor_press_v1","root_at_anchor":"spider_vendor_press_v1"}],"axiom_id":"axm_716fd6628b213940090641cf8bf9b0f4e8e44ffe819e984cdeac58f943f82c5f","axiom_type":"AX.OBS","body":{"axiom_subtype":"news.vendor_press.v1","category":"news","fingerprint":"6f4df823fa0ca8501b222ac81a9b8fecd92a23d81073b011d25b9b3dbf8e110c","published":"Thu, 07 May 2026 00:00:00 -0400","receipt_hash":"6f4df823fa0ca8501b222ac81a9b8fecd92a23d81073b011d25b9b3dbf8e110c","schema":"spider.news.vendor_press.v1","spider":"vendor_press","spider_record":{"axiom_subtype":"news.vendor_press.v1","category":"news","decision_hint":"POSITIVE","envelope_target":"AX.OBS","fingerprint":"6f4df823fa0ca8501b222ac81a9b8fecd92a23d81073b011d25b9b3dbf8e110c","observed_at":"2026-05-07T04:43:30.601849Z","parent_run_hash":"b20b3beeadde500bb99eda3b869d50b00c5259b2c78c650d83e786ac81b85801","published":"Thu, 07 May 2026 00:00:00 -0400","runtime_version":"0.1.0","schema":"spider.news.vendor_press.v1","source_status":200,"source_url":"https://export.arxiv.org/rss/cs.AI","spider":"vendor_press","summary_excerpt":"arXiv:2605.03936v1 Announce Type: cross \nAbstract: Conceptual analysis -- proposing definitions and refining them through counterexamples -- is central to philosophical methodology. We study whether language models can perform this task through iterated analysis and repair chains: one model instance generates counterexamples to a proposed definition, another repairs the definition, and the process repeats. Across 20 concepts and thousands of counterexample-repair cycles, we find that, although many LM-generated counterexamples are judged invalid by both expert humans and an LM judge, the LM judge accepts roughly twice as many as humans do. Nonetheless, per-item validity judgments are moderately consistent across humans and between humans and the LM. We further find that extended iteration produces increasingly verbose definitions without improving accuracy. We also see that some concepts resist stable definitions in general. These findings suggest that while LMs can engage in philosoph","title":"The Counterexample Game: Iterated Conceptual Analysis and Repair in Language Models","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.03936","vendor":"arxiv_cs_ai"},"summary":"arXiv:2605.03936v1 Announce Type: cross \nAbstract: Conceptual analysis -- proposing definitions and refining them through counterexamples -- is central to philosophical methodology. We study whether language models can perform this task through iterated analysis and repair chains: one model instance generates counterexamples to a proposed definition, another repairs the definition, and the process repeats. Across 20 concepts and thousands of counterexample-repair cycles, we find that, although many LM-generated counterexamples are judged invalid by both expert humans and an LM judge, the LM judge accepts roughly twice as many as humans do. Nonetheless, per-item validity judgments are moderately consistent across humans and between humans and the LM. We further find that extended iteration produces increasingly verbose definitions without improving accuracy. We also see that some concepts resist stable definitions in general. These findings suggest that while LMs can engage in philosoph","title":"The Counterexample Game: Iterated Conceptual Analysis and Repair in Language Models","vendor":"arxiv_cs_ai"},"confidence":{"method":"deterministic"},"decision":"POSITIVE","issued_at":"2026-05-07T04:43:30Z","notes":"Spider vendor_press (news) news.vendor_press.v1","object":{"captured_by":"crovia.spider.vendor_press","primary_source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.03936"},"predecessors":[],"schema":"crovia.axiom.v1","signature":"ed25519:14cfa2505f59b6768aba34acdd6057a792f646282503f5541d5da4c9f4f9ce55110cb9bda9634badf999ffc5afb906b6abdfaffaf0fd316faa995bc5ec945b0b","signer":"crovia.substrate","subject":{"observed_at":"2026-05-07T04:43:30Z","source_collector":"spider:vendor_press","target_id":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.03936"},"tsa":{"authority":"crovia.substrate.bootstrap","rfc3161_token":"{\"kind\":\"crovia.bootstrap.tsa\",\"source_jsonl\":\"/opt/crovia/spider/data/news/vendor_press_v1.jsonl\",\"source_seal_merkle_root\":\"spider_vendor_press_v1\",\"upgrade_path\":\"Sessione H \\u2014 OpenTimestamps weekly anchor\"}"},"zk_mode":"clear","zk_proof":null},"ledger":{"leaf_hash":"fa4df7262aa2c4adf1191b15b05276af03723e985c1f8cf55cba5c5ff595f572","leaf_index":118337,"ledger_path":"/opt/crovia/substrate/axiom_ledger.jsonl"},"merkle_proof":{"hash_alg":"sha256","leaf_prefix":"0x00","node_prefix":"0x01","odd_leaf_rule":"duplicate_last","path":[{"sibling":"8693c035799cc6eaa4120ccce71b0c9caa102b36bee579b5a0914fb5d4036767","side":"left"},{"sibling":"89ff5aac37f80b49e3d5aaf6b71dbc0922cef137de6915d13a9e52baca0b05f4","side":"right"},{"sibling":"9ab30e759bba8c7ce87bd2836702386eab061c999694931fa4d2406e79f74dc9","side":"right"},{"sibling":"a65e48ed27583cb9120f9c194d9606bb433629bffa7bf9bebf07670f35fbcbf1","side":"right"},{"sibling":"6604881c25b06c44edf6887bbb8a5c150d61a85381f5341ed6f8ec17f6ea3ca0","side":"right"},{"sibling":"f58ec413562d190637da870490bdc3f4375872692ec9c0bf9c0edfd6dc6faed2","side":"right"},{"sibling":"32aaccf2eeff13821f2f71ee191f0ee0b074a7efb07f37d041ab73d669ff43ba","side":"left"},{"sibling":"432e5b2cf8e49f6f70fd5be7683dbbc02f1ebeff16b82fade70feaeeff078cab","side":"right"},{"sibling":"943780ddf0bc6538ed8b19cdb0e84ad78f5880f72d472b378c67229ade3fd90d","side":"right"},{"sibling":"9e688ad7df5f10379f7d9b9d109c3ea84968c044c36d5562f359706d012cf15b","side":"left"},{"sibling":"8e758a4477dfc0838d2e8ea2bdbd583bc3192683e75fd9cde217ee6a3b2f3ac8","side":"left"},{"sibling":"4219f746e463e594ccd6447debdf736a57e77319b12bcb74d8ece2b5860064c6","side":"left"},{"sibling":"05f89b32c00462e60adf95c1fe4579cdc2791b36e8b17573d8f3b5fd5da95a0b","side":"right"},{"sibling":"8ccd9937a2c0d5c04044d07d1557791b7d07bb31eac41a39a675608d44b38f23","side":"right"},{"sibling":"3a5e69cf0803f4c91f3895ed7c9a95748fef240bec4422e167c05300f79f06c0","side":"left"},{"sibling":"f2817ab288b5324fe49770372c7a10f33f7cd11005f8d4c0a730316f5229dc98","side":"left"},{"sibling":"725fac972e772ca0dc598810ea1abc70df472f72d2d6ab8a0baee2b80e5d2f4c","side":"left"},{"sibling":"98fc57dfef8873b512edc8340f7181df57302bb96777625e072235c62d7c5895","side":"right"}]},"schema":"crovia.axiom_proof.v1","seal":{"first_collector_run_id":"","first_receipt_hash":"","jsonl_path":"/opt/crovia/substrate/axiom_ledger.jsonl","key_id":"430895f101d38164","last_collector_run_id":"","last_receipt_hash":"","leaf_count":134292,"merkle_root":"77fc9c28fae777b81da5b495b3115474df6592dfac590333213d3bdf8b94a9b3","public_key_hex":"cf742e26f75669dc673cb5c0786a1ae23ae8ca19c347317192ce40c28a7ff25c","run_id":"hourly_json_retrofit_20260515T023701Z","schema":"crovia.seal.v1","seal_family_version":"crovia-seal-family/1","seal_kind":"substrate_batch","sealed_at":"2026-05-15T02:37:25Z","sig_algorithm":"ed25519","signature":"68107a834b00b24f5d4501e5ec727445311f132a486567ecc4c72a4e6dff24c8c21f2de3105293353ba5fdbe370d032819af6aa70f694e2e39b6af6737507009","signer_version":"1.1.0"},"trust_root":{"key_id":"430895f101d38164","public_key_hex":"cf742e26f75669dc673cb5c0786a1ae23ae8ca19c347317192ce40c28a7ff25c","signature_algorithm":"ed25519","url":"/registry/canon/TRUST_ROOT.md"},"verifier":{"spec":"/registry/canon/AXIOM_RECEIPT_v1.md","url":"/v/axm_716fd6628b213940090641cf8bf9b0f4e8e44ffe819e984cdeac58f943f82c5f"}}