{"_canonicalization":{"envelope_id":"axm_ + sha256(envelope minus {signature, axiom_id, anchors})","envelope_signature":"ed25519(envelope minus {signature, axiom_id})","json":"sort_keys=True, separators=(',',':'), ensure_ascii=False, allow_nan=False, utf-8","leaf_hash":"sha256(0x00 || canonical_json(envelope_full))","seal_signature":"ed25519(seal minus {signature, sig_algorithm})"},"axiom_id":"axm_b060ea7737251abaf81923106019eeaee01fdf23944d7c7006cf3a2b5f92e329","bitcoin_anchor":{"bitcoin_attestations":[],"calendar_attestations":[],"ots_url":"","stamped_at":"","status":"pending_next_stamp"},"envelope":{"anchors":[{"chain":"crovia.axiom_graph","height":1784196008,"merkle_proof":"tpa_chain_h286061","root_at_anchor":"tpa_chain_h286061"}],"axiom_id":"axm_b060ea7737251abaf81923106019eeaee01fdf23944d7c7006cf3a2b5f92e329","axiom_type":"AX.NEC","body":{"canon_version":"NEC-v1.0","observation_epoch":1784196008,"observations":[{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xa74f7d2db48ccbd73abae3397625990433fbae85ebd08975c7df9ceb3034612d","commitment_y":"0x6d1c6a629a800f53d54a9b23bdb2f6045b94227845688973fbc50f94273faf14","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":true,"necessity_id":"NEC#1","necessity_name":"Missing explicit data provenance","severity_label":"CRITICAL"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xc272dc08340a1e02cb8ad9999aa725f74d64c4dbba663fdf22d3380fa8eff3cc","commitment_y":"0xe34f9f409e4ed7131de2410196d5ecaef460d1f839bb1975b959668c88b0f018","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":4,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","EU General Data Protection Regulation","California Consumer Privacy Act"],"necessity_id":"NEC#10","necessity_name":"Missing temporal validity and revocation metadata","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xbfab70aad434d7a12b6e3efd5a902f9b90fe3941320cd7093188637eef43fffb","commitment_y":"0x4ecf18f98fb7a5f9b0e242e95bc9030eb7c9eadce37f0180fc677b06882950fe","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","United States FTC Act","OECD AI Principles"],"necessity_id":"NEC#11","necessity_name":"Missing known limitations documentation","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xbe55b46ada14ffc1d1f873fd856e331b6ea4c6f9ef5369ec5f2603c55b9e5760","commitment_y":"0x5fe80b9949709e380a2d94f0323d45b044d3e076aafecb5718ce7bc5a618c41e","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":4,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","EU General Data Protection Regulation","United States FTC Act"],"necessity_id":"NEC#12","necessity_name":"Missing bias and fairness assessment","severity_label":"CRITICAL"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x3eb366d5f9e93bd7956aeed6e80be3b397ac93792004e3ac058f15a055da5cde","commitment_y":"0x4dad23d69552cdb159a5c91afd022cfbc8a8c4e9f3af5bacfb5fdfcdd881fd5e","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":true,"necessity_id":"NEC#13","necessity_name":"Missing accountable entity","severity_label":"CRITICAL"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x77fa0fc57df94128a2efa840c2915e0579b432ac82734ac1425ab627a2ab8dd6","commitment_y":"0xbe7cd63824f70e770986a8826897af1816b60356e023278b4a9e1e8d35810be5","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":2,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System"],"necessity_id":"NEC#14","necessity_name":"Missing data preprocessing documentation","severity_label":"MODERATE"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x6e244404f43a665c3ae0f8e68c35b4cb7681b492a7f593e0e53edce00f14a119","commitment_y":"0xd0e4ba3c2927adc56e4b749c576507e742dc73ea7bd6068639596c9d9b799dc6","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":2,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","China Provisions on Generative AI"],"necessity_id":"NEC#15","necessity_name":"Missing multilingual capability scope","severity_label":"LOW"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x8d3676ce3e6b88463e2b405d637bb67bd2efd23fd14a220df6b44bd09a0706c0","commitment_y":"0x166dd0ceafd532e38b7c339a1e7808b77c6def5e0fad1f0e2a9c821be92965a","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System","United Kingdom AI Regulation"],"necessity_id":"NEC#16","necessity_name":"Missing security vulnerability assessment","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x8f396330f18e1cccdc15c0ddb7085f0f50074cf99ac63baf19c16345efc61098","commitment_y":"0x890538de14b726c2f45a21c37ac795ac57cf41b6e648fe27220fa8632283b79f","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":2,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System"],"necessity_id":"NEC#17","necessity_name":"Missing deployment and integration guidelines","severity_label":"MODERATE"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xca557a051da9f7e8495bedd54dac64b38252459d43258fef574069e73ee471fd","commitment_y":"0xa9778d6f2bd6bb925ba14d5c534a3ab9cb9b3a0ddfbe920298118097407f2a97","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","China Provisions on Generative AI","United Kingdom AI Regulation"],"necessity_id":"NEC#18","necessity_name":"Missing incident reporting mechanism","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xd3ddf138d3ba2d67539aa70b86bbf9842b5e35720053fa7b5b9a464d9701c3b5","commitment_y":"0xc71424e357db226e7aba1939b71629d457aa6d115fadde5c22c0d62ab4a4fda9","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":2,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System"],"necessity_id":"NEC#19","necessity_name":"Missing version history and changelog","severity_label":"LOW"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xc4bf69061bb0f51415b1e7f8aa3a4c5d13048676b3b3c5025fb0dbb729dd3c74","commitment_y":"0x52c1396b1ea4c118fad1da4bf6fdecc1021744132ccbf7f1aeb624aec3ae67a6","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":true,"necessity_id":"NEC#2","necessity_name":"Missing explicit license attribution","severity_label":"CRITICAL"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x8b37f9d4031a6dcdf7cce7188497007b6e9bac3951e2208dc0cd70fe7c9aefef","commitment_y":"0x3c488d276329eabcd44910c2c9de9ddbd0ba0145bd0f989de95092fe08ee3afe","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","EU General Data Protection Regulation","OECD AI Principles"],"necessity_id":"NEC#20","necessity_name":"Missing downstream impact assessment","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x9488b4b896cb3b91e0b0b5f8d56b21269935bc729daa479d9cbf147bddc7957b","commitment_y":"0x7ff986a56af811c201ea5ca3b96a33e4c7a33fdd7c49f0b8a8dae79c6cced797","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","China Provisions on Generative AI","OECD AI Principles"],"necessity_id":"NEC#3","necessity_name":"Missing model architecture disclosure","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xad79f25e2f46f3b3dc0998ff88c4a4db7261146f09dc685d58e60ae09c3654ab","commitment_y":"0x3549771214616b4ed879a37816d849bd2f2aadadb1fc7497e40b8b64f4f78a2d","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System","OECD AI Principles"],"necessity_id":"NEC#4","necessity_name":"Missing training methodology documentation","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x8c2b0b58a2d38f15f5ffda527831ecc5a5eac8bfbfc2dd48e7d8cd8784c5980a","commitment_y":"0x1e4008d1d3bbc9dab834ac256ea7752ec2f788bda5940f8ddb667df89ed600f","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","United States FTC Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System"],"necessity_id":"NEC#5","necessity_name":"Missing evaluation and benchmark results","severity_label":"MODERATE"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x64518562113879ef8137924ee8188e638164d43aac72005e78d1a1d9e6e7893","commitment_y":"0x3bf58aa34256b79bb87e9f601a5151e14bc6cfeea503eeb65b85a0366adbceec","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":4,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","China Provisions on Generative AI","United Kingdom AI Regulation"],"necessity_id":"NEC#6","necessity_name":"Missing safety and risk evaluation","severity_label":"CRITICAL"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x1db470b082a7abdef981187feae4ddd2a2e4141d9c1f8b173727a53f5ee3b1d5","commitment_y":"0x1437bd533b5ee9c6395844e1dc077b3ddcb9b9e2fb035471f6c672b2b5294834","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":3,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","United States FTC Act","OECD AI Principles"],"necessity_id":"NEC#7","necessity_name":"Missing usage scope declaration","severity_label":"HIGH"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0x6f87853d03fcd534c7024c22ceea8326d26cd1ad8d02619de8b032880eeaf689","commitment_y":"0x592b706fb27afc892eb21ccd929f768e96699275770ce0840e2618c08a29c91d","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":2,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","ISO/IEC 42001 AI Management System"],"necessity_id":"NEC#8","necessity_name":"Missing environmental impact disclosure","severity_label":"MODERATE"},{"blinding_factor_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","canonical_input":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","commitment_x":"0xe2c827456bdb69fac7c910650436c4d13890df6e0e385e2e173ba282eda05ae","commitment_y":"0x2f3ad38a0ec9545deac15bd9b22004fb65da085c836f3c228d1c37147e5ef4dd","committed_value_hex":"[REDACTED — Crovia PRO]","is_present":false,"jurisdictions_affected":4,"jurisdictions_hint":["European Union AI Act","China Provisions on Generative AI","United Kingdom AI Regulation"],"necessity_id":"NEC#9","necessity_name":"Missing human oversight mechanism","severity_label":"CRITICAL"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-16T10:00:08Z","receipt_hash":"6146adc00c15a99c393d17ab2695580b3df2b0517bdf82c8713d30b93b9d7c4e","tier":"OPEN","tpa_id":"TPA-bf9e78931749565ab79d5aba","version":"1.0.0"},"confidence":{"method":"deterministic"},"decision":"POSITIVE","issued_at":"2026-07-16T10:00:08Z","notes":"TPA TPA-bf9e78931749565ab79d5aba retrofitted from Crovia TPA chain","object":{"captured_by":"crovia.tpa.canon_nec","primary_source_url":"https://registry.croviatrust.com/api/tpa/TPA-bf9e78931749565ab79d5aba"},"predecessors":[],"schema":"crovia.axiom.v1","signature":"ed25519:525d3232ccd8307067204f965122a6d38b07b25610110a3548457a37e7daa733cf82322ba9db2b8d7853199db08438fe8ecc9e7b111c3b025518f05b34166e08","signer":"crovia.substrate","subject":{"source_collector":"tpa_v1","target_id":"ieasybooks-org/shamela-waqfeya-library"},"tsa":{"authority":"crovia.substrate.bootstrap","rfc3161_token":"{\"kind\":\"crovia.bootstrap.tsa\",\"source_jsonl\":\"/var/www/registry/data/tpa_latest.json\",\"source_seal_merkle_root\":\"tpa_chain_h286061\",\"upgrade_path\":\"Sessione H \\u2014 OpenTimestamps weekly anchor\"}"},"zk_mode":"clear","zk_proof":null},"ledger":{"leaf_hash":"c1e069f6ad1f70aae95d6a38384d03e7954864d453cfb33de047921973ed0033","leaf_index":320646,"ledger_path":"/opt/crovia/substrate/axiom_ledger.jsonl"},"merkle_proof":{"hash_alg":"sha256","leaf_prefix":"0x00","node_prefix":"0x01","odd_leaf_rule":"duplicate_last","path":[{"sibling":"14d62cfa317e99b18637a4bb36d6cb76beb8b95d17abca3ab8eb3e0da4890c44","side":"right"},{"sibling":"3b5675d98db834bb4f300b0996af4a978de798e89e354019c58b48200371b504","side":"left"},{"sibling":"8a887e8ed3cd33c754d29212583d70f9b2a57534faba1296bb37db593e6327d9","side":"left"},{"sibling":"4113426f2f8cac292694c892e86ca30d0211a653b8265495e0ed8123e055ff00","side":"right"},{"sibling":"5dfe13ff3579ec2e16fc9cf4a667c5d570160e6ff4c37289925c5bb4e73aa9fb","side":"right"},{"sibling":"723fcf1c4e207f28dbf2509fc3508e4a58a20556a74f552174a9504f6e3c7ace","side":"right"},{"sibling":"932735682e80b614638452fb2ff611c82a89bbdde917621a94b72c9237c577d4","side":"right"},{"sibling":"6ddce0c517659a5b4a50db0fd5917b4470feb76c3cb49d448f8435946b25ba79","side":"left"},{"sibling":"e486d2fe36b70bb5366248a9b149e5253fb61baa9f327a6c4cd6ceb4a5a06d39","side":"right"},{"sibling":"6e23b7ae3540ac754d23622395eb96eeb4a7548203a87351119a716fcd7a6133","side":"right"},{"sibling":"5e95c93e4f01bbaa1318328ce96b3f8b339bd8b3a6164efc669d28aa47894a3b","side":"left"},{"sibling":"ef0d3ba17c9b95c778abfad69ed053f6a2c53370e24cb5dbd6adfa16d63375f2","side":"right"},{"sibling":"a1526248cd96feb7a9301ce672c44ca0335e845c5ce5390e6436165336707121","side":"right"},{"sibling":"34d85f6ad6cc7dfa79d90e2b9ff99a561bcdc75b0301bbbd3e83861f54535c1e","side":"left"},{"sibling":"f302542c38ba7c3aab7c9280dd60259ecec777dca6e6f71b6f0729b0b8791b72","side":"left"},{"sibling":"d8b9143917b539c543cf4448cec00131f8b807bd8004979c54ebe09798748c66","side":"left"},{"sibling":"ae9d1867ddf9357924e27cc6b89eb08924695b7893eca91d641fccbd0613082a","side":"right"},{"sibling":"2286c198b29fbaa30f9017058720a7d99564db29c64adbdabcb894177d39cced","side":"right"},{"sibling":"1cecb7f447febd025aac272837c80de218aecc6485d2395a509b2a1f1b9c746e","side":"left"}]},"schema":"crovia.axiom_proof.v1","seal":{"first_collector_run_id":"","first_receipt_hash":"","jsonl_path":"/opt/crovia/substrate/axiom_ledger.jsonl","key_id":"430895f101d38164","last_collector_run_id":"","last_receipt_hash":"","leaf_count":320697,"merkle_root":"09c5dccf50bf45380c40700a376777135536ff0a7b47bc8f9cedd5ed0edb971a","public_key_hex":"cf742e26f75669dc673cb5c0786a1ae23ae8ca19c347317192ce40c28a7ff25c","run_id":"hourly_json_retrofit_20260716T103701Z","schema":"crovia.seal.v1","seal_family_version":"crovia-seal-family/1","seal_kind":"substrate_batch","sealed_at":"2026-07-16T10:40:37Z","sig_algorithm":"ed25519","signature":"e564007af75c2563b8094ac3be557bb67637798d85dda65f12a217ff9c2305c26350c2e9e00896fc64385cff3838b08afb879f32147aa7fea6cf130ac183790e","signer_version":"1.1.0"},"trust_root":{"key_id":"430895f101d38164","public_key_hex":"cf742e26f75669dc673cb5c0786a1ae23ae8ca19c347317192ce40c28a7ff25c","signature_algorithm":"ed25519","url":"/registry/canon/TRUST_ROOT.md"},"verifier":{"spec":"/registry/canon/AXIOM_RECEIPT_v1.md","url":"/v/axm_b060ea7737251abaf81923106019eeaee01fdf23944d7c7006cf3a2b5f92e329"}}